For the second time in about two weeks, drug manufacturer AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP has sued Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc., alleging infringement by Mylan on its patent for cholesterol drug Crestor. Here is the complaint, which was filed in United States District Court for the Northern District of West Virginia on December 28, 2007, and assigned to Chief Judge Irene M. Keeley. AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP, et al. v. Mylan Laboratories, Inc., Civil Action No. 1:07-CV-00177.
In the action, AstraZeneca alleges that Mylan has infringed on its patent for Crestor, which is used to treat high cholesterol, by seeking FDA approval for rosuvastatin calcium tablets, which is the generic version of Crestor. According to the complaint, Mylan’s position before the FDA is that AstraZeneca’s patent for Crestor is invalid and unenforceable. Among other relief, AstraZeneca asks that “the effective date of any FDA approval of the Mylan Rosuvastatin Calcium Tablets shall be no earlier than the expiration date of the ‘314 patent….”
On December 11, AstraZeneca had filed suit against seven generic drug manufacturers, including Mylan, in United States District Court in Delaware, alleging their infringement of its Crestor patent. AstraZeneca’s complaint against Mylan is virtually identical to its West Virginia filing. AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP, et al. v. Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc., Civil Action No. 1:07-CV-00805. The other generics manufacturers named (in separate complaints) are Sun Pharmaceuticals Industries, Ltd., Sandoz Inc., Par Pharmaceutical Inc., Apotex Inc., Aurobindo Pharma Ltd., and Cobalt Pharmaceuticals Inc.
In other Mylan litigation, Judge Keeley has denied the motion to dismiss filed by Eliot Disner in Mylan’s legal malpractice lawsuit against him. Here is Judge Keeley’s order, which was entered on December 21, 2007. On the same day, she also entered an order staying the case, based on a pending arbitration that may affect its outcome. She has given the parties until March 3, 2008 to report on the status of the arbitration. For some background on Mylan’s claims against Disner, here is my post from last August.
Finally, one more item of interest about Mylan, which does not involve litigation (yet). Mylan’s chief operating officer, Heather Bresch, is accused of receiving an MBA from West Virginia University without satisfying the degree requirements when she was in the program nearly a decade ago. Bresch, who is the daughter of West Virginia Governor Joe Manchin, was named COO in October, at which point the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette called WVU to verify her academic credentials. According to the Post Gazette, which first reported on the situation on December 21, WVU initially said that Bresch did not have an MBA, then reversed its position a few days later, and explained that the discrepancy in its records was caused by the College of Business and Economics’ failure to transfer records for almost half her course work to the Office of Admissions and Records.
As reported by the Post-Gazette, earlier this week, WVU Provost Gerald Lang named a three person panel to determine whether he did anything wrong in determining that Bresch had earned an MBA. And today, the Post-Gazette published this editorial, which questions whether an out-of-state panel may have more credibility in investigating the allegations about Bresch’s degree.